Subscribe Contribute Advertise Facebook Twitter Instagram Forums Newsletter

Reader Reviews

Add your own review

Seychelle In Line Eliminator

in Hydration - Water Treatment

Average Rating
2.00 / 5 (3 reviews)


Display Avatars Sort By:
Stephen Eggleston
( happycamper )

Locale:
South Bayish
Seychelle In Line Eliminator on 12/10/2005 07:07:38 MST Report Post Print

Rating: 2 / 5

I have used this filter for about 2 years. There are several 'pros' about this filter, a few 'cons' and one concern.
The Pros: no chemicals involved, very light for a filter, the in-line idea is very functional, no pumping, no wait, doesn't clog easily(with care), simple/sturdy/easy care, water tastes good, economical
The Cons: not SUL, hose/barb connections will leak in time(easy fix), a bit bulky for hands free hydration
The Concern: How well does it filter?? I've been getting 'the runs' when I go out. During my next outing I will use Aqua Mira to find out if it is the filter or me.

Update(12/06): Well I have been using Aqua Mira exclusively for about 1 year now and can now say (based on personal observation only) that using the Seychelle gave me 'the runs'. My theory is that the Seychelle filter just doesn't have a small enough pore size to be effective for my GI system. I would now only use this filter in conjunction with a chemical treatment.

Edited by happycamper on 12/14/2006 20:22:15 MST.

Ken Helwig
( kennyhel77 )

Locale:
Scotts Valley CA via San Jose, CA
Seychelle Filter on 12/10/2005 16:26:03 MST Report Post Print

Rating: 2 / 5

I too like the idea of this filter. The problem that I have had is getting the runs too. This has now happened a few times. Wonder if the filter is working at all.

Shop Wonder products at GearBuyer
Aaron Wallace
( basilbop )
Good concept, questionable quality on 12/12/2005 12:01:20 MST Report Post Print

Rating: 2 / 5

I had hoped to use the Seychelle to replace the no-longer-available SweetWaterAnywhere inline filter, which IMHO was a superior product. I have two concerns about the Seychelle: 1) The threaded nipple/o-ring used to connect the inner filter element to the housing is very weak--on one filter I received the nipple was broken due to over-tightening at the factory. On another unit, the o-ring had been pinched by the threads, resulting in a questionable seal. 2) When flushing the filter (as recommended), a significant amount of water squirts out from the seam between the filter element and its plastic base (based on three separate units). Both of these issues *could* result in water bypassing the filter element. I have no way to determine if the filter actually does allow unfiltered water to bypass the filter element, but these two issues reduced my confidence in the unit sufficiently that I chose to use an alternative treatment method.

Add your own review