November 20, 2015 8:16 PM MST - Subscription purchasing, account maintenance, forum profile maintenance, new account registration, and forum posting have been disabled
as we prepare our databases for the final migration to our new server next week. Stay tuned here for more details.
Subscribe Contribute Advertise Facebook Twitter Instagram Forums Newsletter

Reader Reviews

Add your own review

Integral Designs Sil Poncho

in Shelters - Tarps & Floorless

Average Rating
4.00 / 5 (3 reviews)

Display Avatars Sort By:
Glenn Roberts
( garkjr )

Southwestern Ohio
Integral Designs Sil Poncho on 10/16/2005 13:49:30 MDT Report Post Print

Rating: 4 / 5

The rating shown here is my guess for the poncho used as a 5x8 tarp. I don't really use mine that way, preferring to carry a separate tarp. However, from the looks of it, it would be as good as any other poncho in a tarp application.

This rates a "5" as raingear, however - I've posted that review under the category: Clothing/Raingear.

Shop Integral Designs products at GearBuyer
joseph daluz
( jfdiberian )

Columbia River Gorge
Nice product on 03/18/2006 17:49:47 MST Report Post Print

Rating: 5 / 5

As raingear: good coverage, hood could use a pull cord to pull back, but when worn with a billed hat, the hood works perfectly
As shelter: quite adequate coverage when used as lean-to with bivy. I mainly use it as ground sheet with a CatTarp and find it to be quite durable, a dozen nights out and not one obvious puncture or tear.
As packcover: I think it works better than the silnylon cover i've been using since there's no gap between the pack and my back, eventually I figured out that I could remove the backpack without removing the poncho, and that's cool!

Shop Nice products at GearBuyer
Antonio Abad
( tonyabad )
Great piece, but set-up aggravations in the rain on 03/19/2006 02:07:13 MST Report Post Print

Rating: 3 / 5

I would have easily given this piece of gear a 5 if it was available in a larger option. As a poncho, it certainly delivers. The drawcords help minimize any flapping at the expense of air circulation/breathability. My issue is with using this piece of gear as a shelter, especially under inclement conditions after a long day of hiking. It just didn't seem possible for me to convert it from poncho/pack cover to shelter without getting soaked in the process. That's the biggest reason why I've switched back to a jacket/tarp combo. The weight savings of combining these two ideas was just not worth what I felt I was giving up: less aggravation in setting up the shelter and more comfort in inclement weather situations. At the end of the day I want to crash with as little fuss as possible (or reasonable given a commitment to lieghtweight backpacking). The 5x8 size also resulted in a less than desirable footprint for me, even when paired with a bivy. I just prefer a little more coverage.

Add your own review