Komperdell Touring Glove Spotlite Review

Gloves made with Komperdell's new seamless bonding construction get a mixed review.

Overall Rating: Below Average

We really like Komperdell's innovative seamless bonding technology, which produces a nicely fitted glove, as well as their three-layer, four-way stretch softshell fabric used in their construction. However, our testing of the Touring Glove revealed the downsides - they are minimally breathable, not waterproof as claimed, and the exterior fabric absorbs water. None of these flaws are acceptable when we are counting on these gloves to keep our hands dry and warm.

About This Rating

Print Jump to Reader Comments

by Will Rietveld and Janet Reichl |

 

Overview

 

Komperdell Touring Glove Spotlite Review - 1
The Komperdell Touring Glove is one of a range of gloves utilizing their "seamless bonding" technology and four-way stretch fabrics. Photo by Bill Webbe.

Komperdell has developed a new "seamless bonding" construction method to produce gloves that are entirely free of seams. Their latest line of gloves are made of a new three-layer softshell fabric with four-way stretch, which are claimed to be waterproof and breathable. All these innovations made us eager to test them out and report on their performance.

In the seamless bonding process, glove parts are assembled using a narrow seam tape (about 13 millimeters wide) and a special adhesive-plus-heat-plus-pressure process. The result is a glove in which all of the joints are butted and taped; there are no sewn seams, and the taped seams are hardly noticeable.

Komperdell Touring Glove Spotlite Review - 2
Close-up of Komperdell's seamless bonding construction, showing the taped seams around the sides of the fingers. The palm side has an anatomic silicone gripper pattern.

Equally innovative is the unique fabric used in the gloves. It is a three-layer softshell construction with four-way stretch. The sandwich consists of a soft nylon outside layer, waterproof-breathable membrane, and a merino wool mix inner lining. According to Komperdell, the membrane functions according to c_change technology. In warm temperatures, the polymer structure opens up, and water vapor and heat escape; in cold temperatures, the polymer structure compresses, becoming wind and water tight and providing more insulation.

Komperdell Touring Glove Spotlite Review - 3
The inside lining is a merino wool and polyester mix, which is soft against the skin and moderately warm.

The first thing we noticed when we donned the gloves was that they run small, so it is best to size up. Will found that size extra-large was a snug fit, but comfortable to wear because the snugness was compensated for by the stretchiness of the fabric. The stretchiness was very noticeable when we closed and expanded our hands and made it easy to grip trekking poles. The silicone pattern on the palms provided a good grip on trekking pole handles - more so on EVA and cork grips, less so on plastic or smooth leather grips.

A range of models is available that utilize the same construction, differing in insulation, wrist closure, and palm coating. Insulated models are a four-layer construction that adds an Isopren layer. We chose the Touring model because it is one of the lightest and most versatile. We used it for hiking using trekking poles and for snow sports using ski poles.

For warmth, we found the Touring glove to be moderately warm, down to about 25° Fahrenheit when active and down to 35-40° Fahrenheit when less active.

During our four months of testing (eleven trips), we found these seamless gloves to be quite durable. Upon close inspection, we did not find any failed seams or areas of specific wear. We used them a lot with poles, and the palm side has held up well to intensive use.

Komperdell claims these gloves are breathable...so how breathable are they? In our field testing in cooler weather, we consistently found that the gloves accumulated moisture (from sweat) inside and felt clammy. Because of the moisture inside, our hands got cold and we had to switch to dry gloves. While hiking uphill at a brisk pace in 50-60° Fahrenheit temperatures, the gloves were damp inside, but our hands did not get cold. It appears that their c_change technology provides some breathability at moderate temperatures.

We tested the gloves waterproof claim by filling the inside of the gloves with sand (in a plastic liner glove) and immersing them in water down to the wrist for one hour. It did not take long to get our answer; after twenty minutes the water level inside the gloves was the same as the outside! Not waterproof, sad to say. Our immersion test was done after three months of use; upon close inspection we found that the gloves leaked in multiple locations, but primarily from the taped seams between the fingers. If you look closely at the second photo above, you will notice that the tape has shifted a bit between the fingers.

Komperdell Touring Glove Spotlite Review - 4
After three months of use, the Touring Glove is not waterproof as claimed. Most of the leakage occurred in the taped joints between the fingers.

Besides a lack of breathability and waterproofness, we found that snow and debris stick to the gloves exterior fabric, and the fabric also absorbs a significant amount of water. We weighed Janet's size small gloves after wetting the exterior and found that the outside fabric absorbed one ounce of water, which is twenty-eight percent of the gloves weight.

Overall, we are impressed with the materials and construction in these gloves, but we are disappointed with their performance. A lack of breathability is a common problem with waterproof gloves, so the gloves get as wet inside from sweat retention as they would from water leaking in. Also, their lack of waterproofness came as a surprise, considering the fabric and construction. Their leakage, combined with water absorption of the exterior fabric certainly does not make them very useful for hiking in wet weather!

Specifications and Features

  • Manufacturer: Komperdell (http://www.komperdell.com/)
  • Year/Model: 2008 Touring Glove
  • Fabrics:: Three-layer softshell (nylon outer, WP/B membrane, and merino wool mix layer on the inside)
  • Features: Seamless bonding technology, silicone gripper palm, Velcro tab closure
  • Weight: Measured weight: Women's small 3.5 oz/pair (99 g), Men's extra-large 4 oz/pair (113 g), manufacturer specification not available
  • MSRP: $79.95 USD


Citation

"Komperdell Touring Glove Spotlite Review," by Will Rietveld and Janet Reichl. BackpackingLight.com (ISSN 1537-0364).
http://backpackinglight.com/cgi-bin/backpackinglight/komperdell_touring_glove_spotlite_review.html, 2008-05-06 00:00:00-06.

Print

Reader Comments

You must login to post comments.

New Visitors: Create a new account
Username:
Password:
Remember my login info.

Forum Index » Editor's Roundtable » Komperdell Touring Glove Spotlite Review


Display Avatars
Sort By:
Ryan Jordan
(ryan) - BPL Staff - MLife

Locale: Greater Yellowstone
Komperdell Touring Glove Spotlite Review on 05/06/2008 23:32:48 MDT Print View

Companion forum thread to:

Komperdell Touring Glove Spotlite Review

Jerzy Ostrzyzek
(turysta) - MLife
Re: Komperdell Touring Glove Spotlite Review on 05/13/2008 18:55:15 MDT Print View

Pleasure to read
All necessary ingredients included
Very helpful in making purchasing decisions