Forum Index » General Lightweight Backpacking Discussion » PCT fire...stove question


Display Avatars Sort By:
Jennifer Mitol
(Jenmitol) - M

Locale: In my dreams....
PCT fire...stove question on 05/03/2013 19:19:17 MDT Print View

I'm letting my ignorance shine here...so apologies in advance.

When there is a fire ban in really dry areas/regions like So Cal right now, does that general imply stoves? Is a canister stove with its shut off valve really that much safer than, say, the starlyte that doesn't spill? Or esbit that is contained? My caldera cone and starlyte stove seem WAY sturdier and safer and more contained than my tall pot perched on a tall soto screwed on a canister...

I'm honestly not trying to be snarky and I hope this doesn't turn into a Max thread (sorry Max, but you know exactly what I'm talking about!), I'm just new to non-canister stoves and reading all the blogs about it has me wondering. What are the stove rules? Or is it common sense, or just campfires....

Discuss.

Bob Gross
(--B.G.--) - F

Locale: Silicon Valley
Re: PCT fire...stove question on 05/03/2013 19:29:20 MDT Print View

"What are the stove rules?"

There is no single set of rules. Each jurisdiction and agency has its own fire rules, and they have their own interpretation of what constitutes a fire. Some places simply mean no open wood fires or campfires. Others interpret that more strictly.

You really have to inquire to each place where you intend to backpack.

--B.G.--

Stephen Barber
(grampa) - MLife

Locale: SoCal
PCT and stoves on 05/03/2013 20:03:36 MDT Print View

I live in the "greater" Los Angeles area, and hike mostly in the Transverse ranges and the southern Sierra. In the national forests of southern California, the "no fires" regulations are generally interpreted as "stoves that can be turned off with a switch". No alcohol stoves, no contained wood stoves, no Esbit. They don't want fires that spark, spill or can't be turned off. So what's left is canister and white gas stoves. At least that's my impression of the rangers' regulations. Perhaps Hikin'Jim will chime in with the expert view for SoCal!

Bob Gross
(--B.G.--) - F

Locale: Silicon Valley
Re: PCT and stoves on 05/03/2013 20:28:50 MDT Print View

"At least that's my impression of the rangers' regulations."

I was standing at the Inyo National Forest station in Bishop as I was getting a permit. The permit person was spitting out some rules and regulations about fire restrictions. Then I asked for one clarification about those rules. Immediately, the person turned around to get the right answer from the senior person in the office, but the senior person was gone. So, the permit guy with me went ahead and answered that clarification. As we were finishing the permit, the senior person came back into the office. The permit person saw him and asked him for the clarification, and we both heard the clarification, which was just the opposite of what I had just been told.

My point is that you almost have to get this stuff in writing in order to depend on it.

--B.G.--

Nick Gatel
(ngatel) - MLife

Locale: Southern California
Re: PCT fire...stove question on 05/03/2013 21:24:29 MDT Print View

Of course check with the local authority. Usually it is WG or canisters as mentioned. Sequoia NF is now a restricted area. BTW if you build a campfire in an approved area you must have a shovel -- it is item #2 on the permit. Some agencies require a trowel if using a backpacking stove -- I was cited for not having a trowel years ago.

Jennifer Mitol
(Jenmitol) - M

Locale: In my dreams....
Re: Re: PCT fire...stove question on 05/03/2013 21:55:23 MDT Print View

So I guess I may not have a choice about my caldera cone vs the soto/canister for the JMT in August, eh?

Richard Cullip
(RichardCullip) - M

Locale: San Diego County
Re:PCT fire...stove question on 05/03/2013 22:02:15 MDT Print View

As Nick said, the Sequoia National Forest has fire restrictions in place as of May 1st. Here's the pertinent part of the notice

•Allowed are: lanterns and portable stoves using gas, jellied petroleum or pressurized liquid fuel outside of developed recreation sites or campgrounds, but only with a valid California Campfire Permit (available free of charge).

•Forest visitors must clear all flammable material five feet in all directions from their camp stove, have a shovel available, and ensure that a responsible person attends the stove at all times when in use.

•Campfires and barbecue charcoal fires are only allowed in developed recreation sites or campgrounds.


Sounds like alcohol and esbit stoves are not allowed. Remember that shovel.

Justin Baker
(justin_baker) - F

Locale: Santa Rosa, CA
Re: Re: Re: PCT fire...stove question on 05/03/2013 22:06:19 MDT Print View

In the high country they usually don't have restrictions based on fire danger. It's mostly just a bunch of rock. The only restriction is a ban on burning wood above a certain elevation for ecological reasons. So I don't think an alcohol stove or esbit should be a problem on the JMT.

Nick, how much did that shovel ticket cost you?
I always thought that was a car camping thing. I would never expect it to be used on a backpacker.

Justin Baker
(justin_baker) - F

Locale: Santa Rosa, CA
Re: Re:PCT fire...stove question on 05/03/2013 22:08:37 MDT Print View

The JMT goes through Sequoia National Park, not Sequoia National Forest.

Hikin' Jim
(hikin_jim) - MLife

Locale: Los Angeles, CA, USA
Re: Re: Re:PCT fire...stove question on 05/03/2013 23:10:39 MDT Print View

A timely discussion.

In all seriousness, I was thinking about this very subject before I saw this thread.

The National Forests are pretty consistent that only "gas, jellied petroleum, or pressurized liquid fuel" are allowed. In other words conventional liquid alcohol stoves are not allowed. The National Parks aren't quite as clear. They talk about wood fires vs. "gas" stoves (white gas? canister gas? They don't say) but don't really mention alcohol stoves.

Maybe it's wishful thinking on my part, but I think ESBIT is a gray area. I was coming to put up a link to my blog post when I saw this thread anyway, so I'll just post it here:
Fire Safety: Alcohol vs. ESBIT in which I discuss the rules and regs as well as the technical merits of each.

By the way, there is smoke from a wildfire blowing in my window occasionally right now, whenever the wind shifts a bit. As I say, this is a very timely issue.

HJ
Adventures in Stoving

Edited by hikin_jim on 05/04/2013 06:26:02 MDT.

Link .
(annapurna) - MLife
Re: Re: Re: Re:PCT fire...stove question on 05/04/2013 07:15:01 MDT Print View

Wizards of The Pct video Considering Your History: A Cautionary Tale

Paul Magnanti
(PaulMags) - MLife

Locale: People's Republic of Boulder
Fire bans on 05/04/2013 13:30:27 MDT Print View

Here's what I found, at least in CO. Suspect other jurisdictions have similar rules.
http://www.pmags.com/stove-comparison-real-world-use#burn-bans

The overall thrust is that during open flame bans, the only acceptable stoves are white gas or canister stoves due to the UL designation (shut off valve) and open flame ban. Again, this was in CO. Parts along the PCT may have different rules.

CT thru-hikers reporter seeing rangers last year asking/reminding people of what stoves to use at USFS road crossings (they did not inspect the packs). It is worth noting a major fire was caused by an alchie stove user. which man explain why CO-based rangers were perhaps a little more vigilant about the rules.

Ultimately, it is one thing to debate online..another thing to ignore the bans just because it is not as convenient for you.

Since I quite literally could see the foothills burning from my deck last year ( and my friends were on evac notice), I tend to take the bans seriously. :)

Edited by PaulMags on 05/04/2013 13:33:06 MDT.

Hikin' Jim
(hikin_jim) - MLife

Locale: Los Angeles, CA, USA
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re:PCT fire...stove question on 05/05/2013 18:36:20 MDT Print View

Anna,

Thanks for that video link. I had seen it before some time ago, but it's good to be reminded of it. I added a section to my blog post about refueling.

HJ
Adventures In Stoving

Susan Papuga
(veganaloha) - M

Locale: USA
Re: PCT fire...stove question on 05/19/2013 02:36:08 MDT Print View

I just came back from doing sections A & B on the PCT. Very dry & hot. I went stoveless, but I remember alcohol stoves being strongly discouraged, if not outright banned.

I will rejoin the trail later this summer, possibly in central/northern CA and I am reconsidering my stove options, if I take one. It may be sacrilage on this site, but I am considering a jet boil canister stove instead of my alcohol stove. I had an incident last year where a stray, swirling wind gust tipped over my alcohol stove, which I thought was secure on a clear, level area and sitting against a rock. Unfortuantely, it caught my fuel bottle nearby as well. The rest is history as they say and the only reason it wasn't a disaster is because it had been raining heavily so the ground was well saturated and I always keep two liters of water on hand for just such an emergency to dose any errant flames. I've never had that happen before and it's not something I want to see again.

If that same improbable, unlikely scenario had happened anywhere in SoCal right now, it would have been a huge disaster. So for me, I don't think I'll be taking an alcohol stove in any dry areas or places with open-flame fire bans. if indeed the Jet Boil Ti Sol is only 8 ounces without the canister, then it's really only about an ounce more than my stove, pot and cozy set up.

I just need to convince myself to spend big bucks for a new jet boil....

Jon Fong
(jonfong) - F - M

Locale: FLAT CAT GEAR
Fire information from the PCTA on 05/19/2013 08:15:49 MDT Print View

Here is a link to the Pacific Crest trail Association and their statements about fire safety. Jon

http://www.pcta.org/discover-the-trail/backcountry-basics/fire/

Edited by jonfong on 05/19/2013 08:37:34 MDT.

Greg Mihalik
(greg23) - M

Locale: Colorado
Re: Re: PCT fire...stove question on 05/19/2013 08:54:22 MDT Print View

Susan,
"...a stray, swirling wind gust tipped over my alcohol stove, which I thought was secure on a clear, level area and sitting against a rock. ..."

More details please. I doubt if there is an alcohol stove user out here who thinks this could ever happen to them. I am certainly one of them.

This is a great opportunity to prevent similar events.

I'm not interested in brands, or finger pointing, or anything else, except the details of the setup - stove type, diameter, height, etc. Pot dimensions. Full or empty. Windscreen? The physical profile that gave the gust an opportunity. Was the fuel bottle open, or closed. Engulfed or vapor trail ignited?

The Colorado fire that Paul mentions was a result of someone bumping the stove and spilling the fuel. (He fled, then drove past dozens canyon of homes and businesses, through town, and an hour later called the sheriff.) So Direct user error on his part.

Your situation sounds very different, and I'd like to know how to avoid it.

Thanks.

Greg

Greg Mihalik
(greg23) - M

Locale: Colorado
Re: Re: Re: PCT fire...stove question on 05/19/2013 09:10:41 MDT Print View

Jennifer,
I was in the same situation a couple of years ago - Caldera Cone, on the JMT.

Since You will have to be able to support your case, and sleep at night knowing you've done everything right, regardless of the opinions and observations posted here you need to personally Call the US Forest Offices and talk to a Fed (not an intern) in the days immediately before your trip to see what is allowed.

I stated explicitly that my "stove" was essentially "an open can filled with alcohol, surrounded by a rigid screen, with a pot sitting on top. And no valve to turn it off". I made it very clear. And everyone I talked to said it was OK. I took names and titles and phone numbers with me. (Some sort of fire ban Was in effect, I don't recall the severity.)

It will be the backcountry ranger that you have to convince, if anyone. Preparation on your part will demonstrate "due diligence", and if there is a misunderstanding, you'll have a good chance of getting the "benefit of the doubt". 99% of those folks are great. They will listen to rational explanations. (I never had to do this, even though I encountered a number of rangers.)

Greg

Edited by greg23 on 05/19/2013 09:28:57 MDT.

Theron Rohr
(theronr) - F

Locale: Los Angeles, California
Re: Re: Re: Re: PCT fire...stove question on 05/19/2013 10:25:47 MDT Print View

I knocked over a tealight stove I was trying out a couple years ago. It was quite embarrassing although no else noticed and it was easy to put out because it's so small. But it's just so easy to do. That experience taught me to be very careful with open alcohol burners in summer time. The tealight stove in particular of course is more knock-over-prone than something solid like a trangia. It's a reminder that some of this stuff is not fool-proof.

Personally I find all the fire regulations very frustrating. Especially that CA fire permit. In the stove list it mentions jellied petroleum. Isn't that napalm? Most people interpret it to mean jelled alcohol like Sterno but that's not what it says. Clearly this stuff is important and yet the forest service can't be bothered to update the permit to account for modern stoves. Do they not care? Are they so mired in bureaucracy and lawsuits that they are powerless? This leaves backpackers like us to debate this stuff endlessly when a written policy would make it clear. I'm left with the impression that whatever you do is fine as long as it seems reasonable and safe as determined by the ranger on the spot. And so the answer to "what stove can I use" is "it depends".

Edited by theronr on 05/19/2013 10:41:38 MDT.

Jennifer Mitol
(Jenmitol) - M

Locale: In my dreams....
Re: PCT fire...stove question on 05/20/2013 09:14:03 MDT Print View

This thread is great. But more than the regulations, I'm want to make sure I'm doing the safe, right thing. As an alcohol stove noobie I need to learn about these fuel disasters and learn how to avoid them.

I did wonder how much safer a no-spill stove, such as the starlyte, might be? I certainly can just take my soto on the JMT...it's not a big deal. I would just prefer my caldera cone. But I also want to do the RIGHT thing.

Nick Gatel
(ngatel) - MLife

Locale: Southern California
Re: Re: PCT fire...stove question on 05/20/2013 09:22:22 MDT Print View

The most important thing to remember is to practice stove safety. This means to clear a large enough area so in case the stove tips over there is no combustible material that can catch fire.

I see a lot of videos (some by BPL members) where the stove is sitting on top or within inches of forest duff and other material that can catch fire -- this includes alcohol and wood stoves!!