I've got the versaliners.
Fit is good. The fleece liner fits snugly and well, but not too tight. Good for dexterity, but even with the little rubber dots on the fingertips and hand, they can be slippery when holding something smooth, such as a smartphone. The shell slides on and off easily, but you lose some dexterity because it is a looser fit. Both the liner and shell have a little pull loop to help you get them on, and this works well.
I've had these for a year, but haven't used them too extensively, so I can't comment on long-term, high usage durability, but so far so good.
Wet...this is something that I wish the pertex shell did better with. Maybe I'm expecting too much from Pertex, but these have wet through many times. Part of the issue is that the seams are not sealed, but when I'm stuffing a cold, wet tarp into its sack, or dribbling water on my hands while getting water from a cold river, my hands always seem to get wetter than I would like.
On the plus side, they are breathable which allows them to dry fast, as can be seen on a cold day and you can watch the steam come through the shell.