Forum Index » GEAR » Brooks Pure Grit- A quick look.


Display Avatars Sort By:
Nico .
(NickB) - MLife

Locale: Los Padres National Forest
MT110 on 02/13/2012 00:01:33 MST Print View

Anton was at a movie showing in SB last week for the film "Unbreakable" which was a documentary on the 2010 western states race.

Anyway part of the film shows Anton using a butter knife to modify the tread on the bottom of his shoes, around the midsole. Looked like he basically cut of the lugs.

In the Q&A after the movie he was asked how many pairs of running shoes he goes through a year. He said about 30!

Chris W
(simplespirit) - MLife

Locale: WNC
Re: Brooks Pure Grit- A quick look. on 02/13/2012 05:35:47 MST Print View

Both of those are interesting to me, but neither would fit. So far the only performance-type shoe I've found shaped correctly for me is the Altra Instinct. The Lone Peak (supposedly on the same last) is too narrow in the toe.

I wore the Instinct on a hike Saturday in the snow. Surprisingly my feet stayed pretty dry over 10+ miles despite the mostly mesh upper.



Anyway, note the more boxy/square nature of the toe box versus most "anatomical" shoes.

Edited by simplespirit on 02/13/2012 05:36:41 MST.

Brendan Swihart
(brendans) - F - MLife

Locale: Fruita CO
Altra on 02/13/2012 06:29:33 MST Print View

Man you people and your wide feet...I tried on some Lone Peaks and felt like I could fit both my feet in one shoe (despite my big toe hitting the end of the toebox). Guess my feet just grew long instead of wide (size 13 usually and I'm 5'8").

Chris W
(simplespirit) - MLife

Locale: WNC
Re: Altra on 02/13/2012 07:12:59 MST Print View

My feet are pretty normal except for the more squared primitive shape across my toes. I credit going barefoot a lot throughout my life and never tolerating pointed shoes.



Oddly the left foot (I'm right footed) appears a little more squared.

Eugene Smith
(Eugeneius) - MLife

Locale: Nuevo Mexico
"Brooks Pure Grit- A quick look." on 02/13/2012 07:41:46 MST Print View

Craig, that wear on the instep is nuts in comparison to the rest of the outsole which looks absolutely rock solid. I think I have gone a bit "soft" in my footwear preference as of late-pun intended- a bit of midsole cushion goes a long way for me and the MT110 was simply too dainty and slipper like of a shoe (*only tried them on and pranced around the house in them). I'm definitely still desire neutral design and minimal differential in the shoe but with some added softness to the ride.

@Nicholas,

'Unbreakable' was a pretty solid flick which kind of consolidated all the last few years of footage, interviews, and hype on all those big name runners into a good documentary. 30 pairs of shoes a year sounds about right considering he has been averaging over 100 miles per week the last few years- insanity! I think those off the chart 200 mile weeks were several years back when he and Skaggs were logging miles when Skaggs set the Hardrock course record and Anton blew Leadville wide open.

@Chris,

You have some seriously wide feet! I've seen the Lone Peaks and played around with them and they are quite wide. Everyone has a different foot shape, so what Altra considers "natural" may not be the case for someone with an arrow shaped foot like myself. I like the wide toe box in the Lone Peak but don't think that I would want such a wide toe box on technical trails and rocky ascents where having a secure fit throughout the full length of the upper is important for me.

Hamish McHamish
(El_Canyon) - M

Locale: USA
_ on 02/13/2012 09:24:11 MST Print View

What are good online sources for Inov-8 shoes in the US? Nobody near me carries them.

Eugene Smith
(Eugeneius) - MLife

Locale: Nuevo Mexico
Inov8 online options... on 02/13/2012 09:52:31 MST Print View

Runningwarehouse.com (*2-day free shipping, Inov8 are usually in stock)

Zombierunner.com (*typically carry Inov8, great customer service)

Eugene Smith
(Eugeneius) - MLife

Locale: Nuevo Mexico
"Brooks Pure Grit- A quick look." on 02/13/2012 10:05:38 MST Print View

@ Chris,

I credit my foot shape to genetics, my entire family on my fathers side has relatively narrow/normal D width feet and long pointed toes (fingerlike!). Do you believe your foot shape is in some way a response to going barefoot and not using narrow shaped shoes when you do go shodded? I've read about this being the case for people but don't quite buy the argument nor understand it.

At work I wear zero drop shoes with no padding for 9hrs, have been for a while now, it feels "natural" and comfortable, but I haven't noticed any changes in the foot shape, but do use my lower legs and engage my feet differently than I did climbing ladders and hauling toolsin while wearing boots in the past.

John Abela
(JohnAbela) - MLife

Locale: www.hikelighter.com
Re: _ on 02/13/2012 10:21:19 MST Print View

@James: What are good online sources for Inov-8 shoes in the US? Nobody near me carries them.


I got my first pair of Inov-8 X-Talon 212 from RunningWarehouse.Com and my second pair from Amazon.Com.

My local "Inov-8 distributor" wouldn't even order them and than a few months ago stopped being a distributor all together. Nearest one to me now is 300+ miles away.

Daniel Smith
(scissor) - F
re pure grit on 02/13/2012 12:28:43 MST Print View

Eugene, what kind of arch do you have?

FWIW I have a flat foot and overpronate and I have about 200 miles on the pure grit. Over time (maybe as the cushioning wore in?) I developed pain on the outside of my midfoot at the end of longer runs. My impression is the grit is built more for an underpronator. I even tried it without the insert and still had issues. The inside of my foot (peak of the arch) was fine it was just the outside. I was interested in the grit as I wanted something minimal with a bit more cushion for longer runs. It is cushioned but not exactly minimal. They are shaped and for my case did not fit my foot. The pain got so bad I am not wearing them anymore. I never had any trouble with my 101s.

Chris W
(simplespirit) - MLife

Locale: WNC
Re: Foot shape on 02/13/2012 12:43:00 MST Print View

@Eugene

I think genetics play a part as well as footwear. As an example, my slightly younger brother can wear narrow/normal shoes fine.

Unfortunately, it only takes a short time with narrow footwear to (mis)shape our feet when we're very young, and it can take a lifetime to undo it. There are obviously varying degrees of what most would consider a wide toed (anatomical per se) shape, and that's likely where the genetics come in to play more (IMO anyway).

Chris W
(simplespirit) - MLife

Locale: WNC
Re: re pure grit on 02/13/2012 12:49:59 MST Print View

@Daniel

If you truly overpronate, a shoe that corrects that should do so by forcing you to supinate (or underpronate) more. A shoe built to correct supination (or underpronation) should cause you to overpronate even more.

I had a very similar issue a few years ago, though, when a store put me in a shoe for an overpronater even though I have a very neutral strike. An 18 mile run in them had the outsides of both feet (instep area) sore for days and I pulled the peroneus brevis in my left leg. I immediately switched back to neutral shoes and haven't had a problem since.

Daniel Smith
(scissor) - F
re Chris on 02/13/2012 13:09:11 MST Print View

Perhaps you are right and I am more neutral now and perhaps this has changed since I switched to minimal? I did use to overpronate at one point. Either way I raise an eye toward what Brooks calls 'minimal' after wearing the shoe. I had no intention of getting a lightweight stability trail runner but that appears to be more of what it is rather than what I view as a 'minimal' shoe.

Eugene Smith
(Eugeneius) - MLife

Locale: Nuevo Mexico
"Brooks Pure Grit- A quick look." on 02/13/2012 22:19:13 MST Print View

I used the term "minimal" in my original post because compared to their other trail shoe offerings, the Pure Grit is relatively minimal in design (flat, simple outsole, sockless liner, minimal overlays) but I don't think Brooks claims this shoe to be a "minimalist" shoe. They do throw around the words "natural" and "anatomical" like it's going out of style however, so yeah, definitely proceed with caution and be an informed runner and know what works for you and what doesn't- not what Brooks claims works for you.

Daniel,

I have a low arch, not completely collapsed but close- my left arch is slightly lower than the right. Despite having a low arch, running in neutral shoes has proven to work best for me and feels best underfoot. The Grits are definitely not as neutral as the 110's, there is some midsole build up in the arch possibly for slight overpronators, but nothing to shake a stick at. I definitely wouldn't call the Pure Grits a stability trainer, but if you're typically running in non cushioned zero drop "barefoot" style shoes, then yes, this is going to be overkill for you. The hefty amount of cushioning is the biggest divergence from the MT110. The thing with the MT101 that I didn't like so much was that it was, yes, neutral, but allowed for too much lateral foot movement due to the floppy mesh upper, it also had a relatively severe drop (9mm) which only seemed to increase as you compressed the forefoot down over time.

Found this article this evening, worth a look for anyone directly comparing the two...

http://ultra168.com/2012/02/14/gear-review-minimalist-trail-shoe-showdown-new-balance-mt110-vs-brooks-pure-grit/

Edited by Eugeneius on 02/13/2012 23:18:35 MST.

Nick Gatel
(ngatel) - MLife

Locale: Southern California
Eugene - Peregrine Question on 02/14/2012 01:03:14 MST Print View

"The Peregrine has been a solid trail shoe for me, both nimble and fast, but offering adequate protection for technical trails and a solid locked in fit with a relatively snug upper. The only real knock for me with the Peregrine is the slightly aggressive taper as you move toward the front of the toebox- small blisters developed on the tips of my toes in the Peregrines during my last ultra run- this was due to the toebox forcing my toes together in response to the repeated pounding and not accommodating for foot swell over the distance. Is this a problem? Only outside of my regular weekly running volume and distances. I haven't eliminated the Peregrine from my quiver."

Eugene,

What if you went up 1/2 size in the Peregrine?

I have been using this shoe (Peregrine) for the past two months on some really steep and rocky trails (1,000' elevation per mile of trail). They have the best traction of any shoe I have ever worn. Normally my shoes are either a 11.5 or 12. The Peregrine's are a little big in the toe box in a size 12, and I almost got a 11.5. I love these shoes!!

Art ...
(asandh) - F
Brooks Pure Grit- A Strong Maybe on 02/26/2012 14:32:08 MST Print View

Tried them on in the store today, and I was very surprised at how much I liked them.
I'm not a minimalist, not even close. These shoes feel like the top edge of minimal or the lower edge of regular shoes.
Fit is Great.
Cushion is great, as long as you are a mid foot or fore foot striker. First shoe I ever tried on that had more cushion in the mid foot then the heal. weird at first to walk in, but then you start running and it totally makes sense.
The shoe feels like it is good for a 50+ mile race as long as you don't have too many miles on them going in to the race.
These shoes are a strong candidate for my next trail shoe purchase in the near future.

Eugene Smith
(Eugeneius) - MLife

Locale: Nuevo Mexico
"Brooks Pure Grit- A quick look." on 02/26/2012 21:58:53 MST Print View

Art,

I'm completely satisfied with the Pure Grit, it's a solid shoe for me. You're definitely spot on in regard to the cushion, which is ample, but still responsive and not 'mushy' in any way. I think Brooks dialed in the durometer of the outsole and midsole, plenty of dampening for aggressive trail and the shoe still picks up and toes off nicely on the flat and mild stuff.

I broke in my 2nd pair of Grits on my long run today, my first pair is slowly nearing the end of it's life and has lost that "pop", the upper is still in excellent condition, minor hole in the mesh on the outer left upper where the forefoot flexes, but the midsole is beginning to go flat and not offer the protection against rocks as it has since early December. Outsole wear on my first pair is not so great on the climbs, especially on face smearing footstrikes where I have to toe off aggressively. I will use the first pair for my weekly runs and save my 2nd pair for my long runs and possibly for our R2R2R if the midsole holds up for the next 6 weeks of runs.

Luke Schmidt
(Cameron) - MLife

Locale: The WOODS
Re Re Foot Shape on 03/07/2012 17:46:58 MST Print View

Chris I have very similar feet to yours. Mind sharing what other shoes have worked for you? I was excited about the NB110 but Craig's review has put a damper on that. NB 101s work OK but they blow out on the side pretty fast. That just happens to be were my wide toes rube the side so they are probably a bit tight and I'm only getting away with it because they're a flexible shoe.

Chris W
(simplespirit) - MLife

Locale: WNC
Re Foot Shape @Luke on 03/07/2012 17:59:29 MST Print View

I've had good luck with 3 options thus far.

The first is the Inov-8 230 sized up considerably. My real shoe size is about a 9.5 and I can make an 11 work in the 230. I went through a couple of pairs over the last two years.

The Altra Instinct is a perfect fit in a 10, but they're a road shoe with no aggressive tread. With that said, I did use them on a couple of trips recently and didn't have any major issues.

I'm currently testing a pair of New Balance Minimus MT00 in the 4E version for review here on BPL. If anything, they're a bit too wide but that isn't a real concern for me personally. These are extremely minimal and if you go tromping through rocky terrain with any kind of recklessness your feet will undoubtedly pay. That said, they drain like a water shoe. I thought the 230s drained fast but these make those look like they hold water.

Edited by simplespirit on 03/07/2012 18:00:39 MST.

Eugene Smith
(Eugeneius) - MLife

Locale: Nuevo Mexico
"Brooks Pure Grit- A quick look." on 03/07/2012 19:56:09 MST Print View

The issue I have with the MT00 is the cutouts on the outsole, which expose your feet to rock bruises and potential debris penetration on anything but tame trails. The "scallops" on the outsole are effective in minimizing the outsole weight and maximizing flexibility, but it is a definite compromise in the area of protection.