First, you might want to establish the printer that you will use, and then select the paper. Some papers work best for black laser. Some work best for color inkjet.
In the past, I have used HP LaserJet Tough Paper and HP Color LaserJet Soft Gloss. These are each pretty tough. I've used many types of color inkjet paper, but if they are ordinary matte papers, they are not plastic, and if they are plastic, they are either heavy or expensive.