Ok, I am planning a 3 night trip to Colorado with a friend summer 2012 and am trying to get the shelter thing figured out ahead of time. This will be his first true backpacking trip, so I think we need to go with a traditional double walled tent to simplify things and give him some sense of comfort. If it was just me, I would bring a tarp or mid, but we are not traveling more than 5-6 miles per day, so the weight is not as much of an issue as comfort is. I do have a new Copper Spur UL4 that I have only set up in the basement a few times. It seems like a nice overall tent. We will possibly be camping at or above tree line several nights, so my main concern is wind worthiness. When testing out the Copper Spur in the very harsh conditions of my basement, it seems that it is rather easy to push on one pole and make it shift considerably. This leads me to think that it might not be the best to use if there is a possibility of high winds. I do like that the solid fabric on the walls extends ½ way up, and I don’t have any concern about waterproofness, just wind stability.
Has anyone used a Copper Spur UL4 in high winds? Doing a search finds some that think it will be ok and some that don’t.
Or should I just sell the copper spur ul4 and use the 1 pound heavier Sierra Designs Lightning XT4 I have also? This in my opinion could handle winds a lot better than the copper spur.
I know we don’t need a 4 man tent, but this is all about comfort for his first trip so he doesn’t get put off by this whole backpacking mess.