Forum Index » GEAR » Comfort/Light Weight


Display Avatars Sort By:
Benjamin Ludwig
(Ender) - F

Locale: Mid-West
Comfort/Light Weight on 12/28/2011 20:47:47 MST Print View

Im hiking the the Grand Canyon from the North Rim to the South in May, and I need to build a pack that will last me about 3 days. I know absolutely nothing about light weight hiking and Im hoping you guys could help me out?

I go camping/hiking all the time, but I usually have my truck near by carrying most of my stuff inside of it. So.. going on a 3 day hike is going to be a learning experience for me, and I could use all the help I can get.

How do I word this... Im not worried about price, but im a cheep skate. That being said, if I find that spending a few extra bucks is going to save my back or get me better sleep.. Id do it in a heart beat.

Temperatures will be around 30F at night and 60F in the day time, nothing to crazy. Lets just say I don't own any equipment and go from there. What do I need to survive 3 days with the best compromise of comfort, weight, and functionality.

Thanks
Ben

Ken K
(TheFatBoy) - F

Locale: St. Louis
That's a wide open question on 12/28/2011 21:13:25 MST Print View

Wow... That is a pretty adventurous first backpacking trek, and "what do I need" is a wide open question. For every person on here, you're likely to get a different recommended gear list.

I'm sure the collective here will be happy to offer advice, but if you could start by clarifying a few things, we can give you more targeted advice. Do you plan on doing this alone? With a small or large crew? If with others, do they have any crew gear already (stove/water filter/tent/etc.)? Do you prefer to tent or tarp it? Willing to try a quilt or prefer to stick with a sleeping bag? Do you plan on making the backpacking thing a regular habit, or is this a one-shot deal?

USA Duane Hall
(hikerduane) - F

Locale: Extreme northern Sierra Nevada
Pack purchase last on 12/28/2011 21:19:12 MST Print View

Well, after you have made all of your gear purchases, then get a backpack to fit it all. It's hard enough to make a decision on one new piece of gear let alone all the gear. Shelter, bag/pad, pack. Shoes to make it happen.
Duane

Stephan Doyle
(StephanCal)
Re: Comfort/Light Weight on 12/28/2011 21:21:37 MST Print View

Budget, budget, budget.

For example, there is a 30º quilt from Katabatic Gear. Depending on your height, it'll run upwards of $400. Walk in to REI and you can probably find something just as warm for $100 or less.

Dan McHale is probably the world's premier packmaker, but you might spend $1,000 (or more) depending on your options. REI will fit you for a pack and give you a plethora of choices under $250.

If you aren't worried about price, everyone can give you their dream setup. Establish at least a rough budget.

Also, everyone has personal preferences. Take a lot of our advice with a grain of salt - we all will give you different advice anyway.

David Thomas
(DavidinKenai) - M

Locale: North Woods. Far North.
Re: Re: Comfort/Light Weight on 12/28/2011 21:29:31 MST Print View

Budget or no budget.

You can rent a backpack, sleeping pad and maybe a sleeping bag from some stores. For a first timer who may or may not like the sport, that's a great option.

You can also fall in with your local hiking group or Sierra Club Chapter. Not only can those experienced people give you a lot of pointers, but by your second or third outing, they'll be offering you their gear to borrow for your trip. It's a great way to try different approaches before you commit/buy.

The biggest thing BY FAR for such a strenous trip is the CONDITION you will be in, not the gear you will carry. There are many blogs and articles on hiking the Grand Canyon. And preparing for it. It is a spetacular trip, but also one of the hardest beginner trips imaginable.

I've done it may times and my enjoyment depends much more all the hikes I did in advance than on my pack weight.

Benjamin Ludwig
(Ender) - F

Locale: Mid-West
My List on 12/28/2011 22:22:20 MST Print View

I know it's a broad question, but I guess that's how little I know. I don't even know enough to make the question more specific.

Im going with 1 other person and I hope to start over night hiking a few times a year atleast. How about I start with what I think I need and then you guys can help me fill in the blanks?

Clothing... check. I have boots, wool socks, layered clothing. Its not Patagonia, but I think it should do.
-2 person tent, weighs about 5 lbs.
-1 Wal-Mart sleeping bag.. (cost me 20 bucks) Should I upgrade?
-I have heard a few things on quilts, not sure which is better.. preference I assume?
-I need a sleeping pad. Suggestions?! Quality/comfy sleep is a high priority for me.
-What do you guys carry for food that keeps for 3 days? MRE's?
-I need cook ware
-I need a pack
-Ive got a Stream Light FLashlight, fire starter, survival knife..etc
-I need an efficient way to carry water. This is a worry for me because I dont know how much to carry. I've never made the hike, and I don't know how much water I will see on the trails.
-Should I get a hiking GPS?

Thats all I can think of right now, what do you think?

Thanks guys
Ben

Jason McSpadden
(JBMcSr1) - M

Locale: Rocky Mountains
Comfort/light Weight on 12/28/2011 22:29:07 MST Print View

I would do some reading in the "Gear List" forum. There are 45 pages of a lot of information on how to put together a gear list of what you will need for this trip.

Good luck--it is a wonderful adventure to the prepared and even the not so prepared.

Fog Mountain
(FogMountain)
Re: Comfort/Light Weight on 12/28/2011 23:41:56 MST Print View

According to the data found on the page linked below, average daily high temperatures in the bottom of the Grand Canyon in May are around 90°F, with record highs in the 100–110°F range. You'll need more than a gallon of water per person per day, and plenty of sun protection (hat, glasses, sunscreen).

Western Regional Climate Center, Inner Canyon USGS, Arizona

I'm not familiar with the trail, so I don't know how many places you can get water along the way aside from the Colorado itself. It wouldn't surprise me if there aren't any in dry weather.

Benjamin Ludwig
(Ender) - F

Locale: Mid-West
temp on 12/29/2011 00:02:45 MST Print View

The inner Gorge ranges from 90-110 degrees, but the North and south Rim are much cooler. Like I said before around 30-60 degrees in may.

Nick Larsen
(stingray4540) - F

Locale: South Bay
Re: My List on 12/29/2011 01:00:52 MST Print View

Take the following with a grain of salt as it is only my opinion and everyone will have a different one.

Also, if u have an unlimited budget and plan on doing this a lot more, I could put together a 6lb. Pack that doesn't sacrifice much in comfort. But I'm going to assume u don't want to spend $2,000 for your first and possibly only trip...

-2 person tent, weighs about 5 lbs. -- that'll work. There's definitely lighter options, but if only one of you are carrying shelter it should offset things. My wife and I carry a 5lb. tent at the moment. Usually one person carries the tent and the other one carries all the food.

-1 Wal-Mart sleeping bag.. (cost me 20 bucks) Should I upgrade? -- Depends on the temperature rating of the bag and your expected lows. If the bag is rated 30F don't expect to be comfortable below 40F. Also, how compact will it get? This may cause issues with packing, but you could also attach it to the outside of your pack.

-I have heard a few things on quilts, not sure which is better.. preference I assume? --preference yes, but will also help save some weight, but I wouldn't worry about it unless you plan to upgrade your bag and are willing to spend some money.

-I need a sleeping pad. Suggestions?! Quality/comfy sleep is a high priority for me. --cheapest and almost the lightest option would be a z-lite ridge rest. Fold it in half and put your pack under your feet. Almost as comfortable as an inflateable. You could go with an inflatable but to get a similar weight it will cost over $100 more. The ridgerest is bulky, but if you strap it outside your pack, you can pull it out at rest stops to sit on.

-What do you guys carry for food that keeps for 3 days? MRE's? --mountain house for dinner. All you need to do is add boiling water. Two packs of instant oatmeal for breakfast. Whatever you want for lunch, trailmix, bars, jerky, another mountain house? Just make sure your getting enough calories each day. No campfires? Look into a caldera cone. A foster's can pot and esbit tabs will probably be your lightest stove/windscreen/fuel option.

-I need cook ware --keep it simple. If you are only cooking for freeze dried meals then you only need to boil water. If you are allowed camp fires then you don't really even need a stove, just a pot and a spork. Aluminum grease pot for $7 is pretty light for it's size, unless you go the caldera cone route.

-I need a pack -- buy this LAST. And if possible go somewhere where you can try the packs on with weight in them. Your not likely going to be carrying less than 20lb., so I would go with an internal frame pack. Give a good look at Deuter brand. Super comfy for carrying up to 40lb. and only run about $150. However, everyone is different that's why I always recommend wearing a pack with the weight of the gear you have in it. One person's dream is another's nightmare.

-Ive got a Stream Light FLashlight, fire starter, survival knife..etc --throw in some band aids, Motrin, pepto, mini bic, whistle, and 10ft of duct tape.

-I need an efficient way to carry water. This is a worry for me because I dont know how much to carry. I've never made the hike, and I don't know how much water I will see on the trails.
--this you need to look into!!! How far between water sources will decide how much you need to carry. Another good reason for a framed pack, as water is the heaviest thing you will carry. I like water bladders. Most packs allow you to carry them close to your back for balance and comfort, and they make it easy to stay hydrated by having the drink tube so easily accessable. You also need a way to filter your water. Look into the sawyer squeeze filter. You may not like iodine or chlorine. ?

-Should I get a hiking GPS? --how good are you with a map and compass? Don't know north from south? Then yes, but play with it and learn how to use it, and make sure you have the map downloaded for your area.

Of course, as someone else mentioned, it may be a cheaper short term option to rent the gear you need.

Hope that helps a little.

Edited by stingray4540 on 12/29/2011 01:51:56 MST.

drowning in spam
(leaftye) - F

Locale: SoCal
Re: Comfort/Light Weight on 12/29/2011 02:37:38 MST Print View

I've read that food can be difficult to protect out there, so you might want to do something about that. I always use an Ursack, and I bet that'd be enough to protect food for you and one other person. The Ursack Minor should work fine if you don't want to buy the bear resistant version.

What's the bugs and weather (wind) like? If both are good, then I'd strongly consider a flat tarp. It'd be very light and inexpensive, and might even give you more pitching options, although you'll need to get familiar with various options for setting it up.

You can get some very nice gear, use it for your trip, and sell it here when you're done. You can even buy it here. If this is your only trip for the gear you're buying, this might cost less than buying cheap gear that you can't sell. If that was my plan, here's what I'd get:

EnLIGHTened Equipment Revelation (down) quilt, 20°F
8x10' flat silnylon tarp with webbing tie outs
ULA Circuit or Catalyst
Ursack (Minor?)
Maybe add a TiGoat bivy

Those things should be pretty easy to sell. A comparable Golite quilt would be easier to sell, but they don't seem to resell for much. You should know that EnLIGHTened only makes quilts after they are ordered, so you should order as early as possible if you want one.

That leaves you with a sleeping pad, clothing, water treatment and lighting. Those things are personal and depend a lot of the type of trip, and are harder to sell. If you can tolerate pads, then a Z-rest is a great solution. I personally wouldn't use a base layer, just boxer briefs...just clean up before crawling under your quilt. I think a puffy vest would be warm enough for your trip. I like puffy headgear like the RayWay bomber hat, but you have to make that yourself. I have no idea what kind of gear is suitable for that hike, but you probably wouldn't go wrong with a Dri Ducks suit. The two options I'd consider for that trip is a Sawyer filter or chemicals like Aqua Mira. I've heard that the water from the river can have a lot of sediment and that letting it sit in a bucket for a while helps to let the sediment settle, but coming up with a similar packable solution is somewhat troublesome. If you put it straight into a filter, you will quickly clog it, but that might not become an issue during your trip. For lighting, I like a bright light with a spot+flood beam pattern. My two favorites are somewhat expensive, especially if you use good batteries. The first is a Zebralight H600. It can be used easily as a flashlight or a headlamp, and is nearly as bright as halogen car headlamps at 750 lumens. It uses a lithium ion 18650 cell that costs $20 for a good battery, and requires a special charger. The second light is a Spark SD52. It can use normal AA batteries and put out 280 lumens, which is still very bright...much brighter than the headlamps most hikers use. It can also use lithium ion 14500 batteries to allow an output of about 500 lumens, and would also require a special charger. Both lights are pretty light, although a little heavier than dim floody lights like the Petzl Tikka, but the weight difference gets smaller when you add the weight of the batteries.

I don't know if you'll be cooking. I don't cook...

Oh yeah, use disposable drink bottles (like gatorade) for your water. They are light, cheap and strong.

Edited by leaftye on 12/29/2011 02:38:55 MST.

James W.
(jimmyjam)

Locale: Mid Atlantic
Comfort/LightWeight on 12/29/2011 06:32:14 MST Print View

Benjamin,

I've been hiking at the GC several times during the same time. The spring weather is somewhat unpredictable. On one late April trip it was 27F at 8am at the rim, snowing, changed to sleet, then to "snow balls", then to rain. When we got to the bottom that afternoon it was 75F +. Be prepared to strip off layers as you go down. Going back up you'll be making enough heat to stay in shorts. Give yourself a day at least to acclimate your body- especially starting at the NRim- elevation is 1,000 ft higher than the south rim. Going down is harder on your knees and toes than going up. Make sure your toes are not jambed in the front of your shoe. Good info can be found on www.hikearizona.com.

Steve Gaioni
(sgaioni) - MLife

Locale: Mid-Atlantic
maybe buy a book or two before buying gear on 12/29/2011 06:35:39 MST Print View

Ben - Since you're starting out in backpacking, you can collect lots of useful advice in this forum. But I bet you'd benefit from buying "Allen and Mike's Really Cool Backpackin' Book", as well as "Ultralight Backpackin' Tips: 153 Amazing & Inexpensive Tips for Extremely Lightweight Camping". Both are available at Amazon and may be the best $25 you can spend at this point.

Sumi Wada
(DetroitTigerFan) - M

Locale: Ann Arbor
Whoa... slow down on 12/29/2011 07:21:44 MST Print View

First of all, permit requests for May go in on Januaray 1st which I assume you're prepared for. But note that, statistically, May corridor permits are the hardest to get, so be sure to have a backup itinerary. North Rim services (including the shuttle) don't open until May 15th, which makes the second half of May the toughest.

Before you go running off to buy gear, I would strongly suggest waiting until you have your permit, so that you know exactly what dates and which camps. The beginning of May is often still "spring" in the Canyon while the end of May is solidly into "summer". And Cottonwood Camp is at 5,000 feet vs Bright Angel campground at 2,500 feet; difference can easily be 15-20 degrees, and usually the difference between carrying a 30-degree bag and a 45-degree bag.

Not sure where you got your temperature predictions; are you including a night at the North Rim? That would be the coldest and, in early May, you should be prepared for snow and freezing temps. Below the rim, in early May, you *might* see 35-degrees (and be prepared for 30) at Cottonwood but, otherwise, it will be balmy, if not downright hot. Nights at the river are going to be in the 50's. In May, you can easily have daytime temps in the 90's below the rim.

Corridor (i.e. North Kaibab, Bright Angel trail) has lots of water (as the Grand Canyon goes, anyway.) So, if that's what you get your permit for, you'll probably never carry more than 2 liters. I'd take an additional liter container in case you have a really hot day.

All of the corridor camps are designated campsites and they each have an ammo box for food protection. *If* you get a non-corridor camp on your permit, you'll want to consider something like an Outsak to protect your food against the mice. The Grand Canyon mice are an especially tenacious bunch.

I never take a tent in the Canyon. I take a tarp but only set it when it looks like rain which, in May, will be rare. The Canyon's a perfect place for sleeping under the stars; little rain and no bugs.

Consider hiking poles.

Ben Crocker
(alexdrewreed) - M

Locale: Kentucky
GC List on 12/29/2011 08:29:15 MST Print View

I would look at the lists of other people on here. Many post gear lists. You may want to add, for the GC, an extra 2 liter platypus, a good hat, and trekking poles. A tarp will probably do there and save you a lot of weight. For a 3 day trip as a beginner, my only cooking would be boiling water and pouring it into a dehydrated meal bag; you'll carry a lot less.

Benjamin Ludwig
(Ender) - F

Locale: Mid-West
GC on 12/29/2011 09:21:23 MST Print View

Exactly what I was looking for guys, thanks a ton.

I can start on my permit Jan 01, so that's what we plan to do. The trip is at the End of May, I got the temperatures off of GrandCanyonHiker.com

James: We want to hike both the North and the South Rim, but un sure of which way to go. North to South or South to North. Does it matter? Do you have a suggestion?

I thought I knew about quilts lol but I guess I do not. When I heard the term I imagined a blanket.. like the heavy duty stuff your grama owns. I looked them up on hiking websites though and they just look like sleeping bags. Help?

Great info guys I really appreciate it.

Ben

Anna O'Leary
(annapurna) - MLife
Re: GC on 12/29/2011 09:47:16 MST Print View

quilt example,they make great quilts

http://katabaticgear.com/shop/category/sleeping-bags/

click on images for a better idea

http://katabaticgear.com/shop/palisade-sleeping-bag/

need to be a member to read this one

http://www.backpackinglight.com/cgi-bin/backpackinglight/2006_unconventional_sleep_systems_manifesto.html

a few good companies to look at

http://www.tarptent.com/allproducts.html

http://www.sixmoondesigns.com/tents.html

http://www.sixmoondesigns.com/packs.html

http://gossamergear.com/packs/backpacks.html

http://www.ula-equipment.com/packoverview.asp

http://www.zpacks.com/

http://www.mountainlaureldesigns.com/shop/index.php?cPath=47

http://www.mountainlaureldesigns.com/shop/index.php?cPath=21

http://www.mountainlaureldesigns.com/shop/index.php?cPath=25

http://www.lightheartgear.com

http://www.yamamountaingear.com/index.php?main_page=product_info&cPath=4&products_id=51

http://www.jacksrbetter.com/Wearable%20Quilts.htm#SierraStealth

http://www.titaniumgoat.com/products.html

http://www.rutalocura.com/products.html

you might like these videos

http://ultralightbackpackintips.blogspot.com/2011/07/video-tutorials.html

Edited by annapurna on 12/29/2011 09:48:33 MST.

Sumi Wada
(DetroitTigerFan) - M

Locale: Ann Arbor
Re: GC on 12/29/2011 10:10:17 MST Print View

>> The trip is at the End of May, I got the temperatures off of GrandCanyonHiker.com

Average temps on the NPS site (bottom of page):
http://www.nps.gov/grca/planyourvisit/weather-condition.htm

Note the "inner canyon" temps for May and June; average high is over 90. Precipitation for May and June are the lowest of the year. If there's no rain in the forecast, take one of those $1 "disposable" ponchos.

I'm also going to say this. As great as the UL gear that's been mentioned is, May conditions in the Canyon are such that you don't need anything more than a cheap 40-degree down bag, something like a Lafuma, that you should be able to pick up for less than $50 on sale. That and a cheap tarp and hiking poles. If you're going to spend money on anything, get a comfortable light pad.

Also, the Canyon is bone dry and it will be hot. This is the one hike that cotton is perfectly fine. In fact, I prefer cotton t-shirts that I can soak in the creek and keep cool. You'll want non-cotton socks, that's all.

Take a few dollars for beer at Phantom Ranch!

Good luck on that permit.

Edited by DetroitTigerFan on 12/29/2011 10:22:59 MST.

James W.
(jimmyjam)

Locale: Mid Atlantic
Re: GC on 12/29/2011 10:34:12 MST Print View

Ben,

From the N Rim to Phantom Ranch it's 14 miles downhill. From the S. Rim to Phantom ranch it's around 9 miles downhill. There are more services on the south rim. Also to consider, the north rim usually doesnot even open until May 15 because of the snow. We were there this past June and there was still snow in the shade with daytime temps at the rim in the low 70s (90 below the rim) and nights around upper 30s on the rim. If you go S to N you will need a night at Bright Angel and a night at Cottonwood. Going N to S you will need a night at Bright Angel and from there you can walk the 9 miles up to the south rim if you start before daybreak- otherwise you may burn up ( or reserve a night at Indian Gardens). Best to hike in the canyon early morning and late afternoon, avoid the mid day to early afternoon heat. Go to www.nps.gov lot's of good info on the canyon there.

If you can't get a permit for that, get a night at Horseshoe Mesa down the Grand View trail- lots of solitude, awesome views, and no donkeys.

Or there are a lot of awesome day hike possibilities.

James W.
(jimmyjam)

Locale: Mid Atlantic
Comfort/Light Weight on 12/29/2011 10:38:18 MST Print View

Ben,

Also you can pretty much rent all your gear from the park's stores on the South Rim.