JT - the Weminuche is gorgeous. You really can't go wrong. I'm not the map-addict that my dad is, but we've spent 6-7 weeks out there, and the trails around Durango, Pagosa, and especially Creede are amazing. You might try leaving from around Creede and see if you can catch the Pyramid and the Window on some sort of loop. Great attractions for first-timers, too.