|
Nate, Not sure if this helps or hurts, but the JRB Hudson River Quilt (no sniveller without head hole) is on sale for $210.
To further complicate or justify going golite. Both the golite ultra and the JRB Hudson/No Sniveller report 2.5" of loft. The ultra 20 I had did loft to 2.5". So I am curious about Andrews comments about significant loft difference between the two quilts. Maybe the difference is in more variation from one run to the next for the ultra 20's...maybe I got a good one? But it should also be noted that the ultra 20 uses 9.5 oz of down compared to 11 oz for the JRB quilts. This would support Andrew over me if both quilts use similar lofting down (800 fill) and have similar surface area. Both quilts have 2" inch baffles.
To give you a comparison. I own or have owned a Golite Ultra 20, A Nunatak Ghost (custom sized and overstuffed), a JRB Stealth (40 degree version of the no sniveller), and a MYOG Thru-hiker Quilt (21 oz, 20 degree).
My assessment is... * The Ghost outperforms all with respect to warmth to weight but is the most confining, it costs alot and the wait is long, mine is 50" wide * The JRB is most versatile (as Andrew points out) and a good value for price, but it is a bit narrow, 48" wide * The Ultra 20 is best mix for the money, it is nice and wide and the longest, at 19 oz is nice on weight, 55" wide * The MYOG is the most personally satisfying, havent used it yet but indications are it will be the warmest of the lot and versatile as it lies flat, 52" wide
If you are just trying out quilts for the first time, the extra width of the Ultra 20 will help make the transition much easier.
Jamie
Edited by jshortt on 11/07/2009 07:15:38 MST.
|