Douglas, Douglas, Douglas...
With this crowd you should realize that you need to be very specific about where, when and how you plan to use your shelter.
Where - northeast US, Arizona, Sierras, Scotland, above treeline, etc.
When - summer, winter, bug season, rainy season, etc.
How - solo hiking vs. with partner, single vs. multiple nights vs. thru hiking, main shelter vs. backup to lean-to
Priorities - weight, cost, flexibility, storm worthiness
Without this information, you are just starting an endless discussion among passionate people...or maybe you're just another of those trouble makers. ;-)